[ ARC forum 2 ]

Re: I will not be used

Written by AJ at 14 May 2003 21:37:23:

As an answer to: Re: I will not be used written by Ralesk at 14 May 2003 20:57:57:

>You could turn that expression around too ;]
>Many pro-circ and especially pro-RIC people will keep saying there is no loss there are no problems look at all those cut Americans they are ALL happy. Not all.
>And define "happy about something" if their knowledge about the certain something is equal to zero. I would call that unawareness rather than happiness. Which is the case of the /vast/ majority of cut (as infant) people.

You’re right, Ralesk, the argument does work in reverse. I totally agree with that. My point is that it’s not a valid argument. It’s just speculative generalising and shouldn’t be presented as a given from any party or persuasion. That'd be just plain inaccurate.

>Taking the uninformed out of the form --- you'll get a quite interesting result.

Unicorn?


Answers: