THE APPROPRIATE TREATMENT
OF PHIMOTIC RING
The causes of phimosis are as individual and varied as the treatment
Following Dr. O.J. Clemmensen's
findings, this simple practical "rule of thumb" conclusion
is suggested:
1) If the subject has a primary or congenital phimosis, i.e. ever
since he can remember, then there is every reason to believe that gentle
stretching will mobilise the elastic capacity of the skin tissue.
2) If on the other hand he can remember the phimotic ring developing
then it is most probably a secondary phimosis of a lichenoid or fibrous
type, such types are atrophic (prone to degeneration), they will generally
be difficult to stretch. Clobetasol Propionate and other steroids may
help, but recurrent problems require surgery. |
Circumcision remains largely unquestioned as the treatment for phimosis.
Circumcision is the oldest routine operation. This operation is the
foundation stone of surgical history and its tradition in Western medicine.
However, in the modern world a full circumcision is usually performed,
whereas the origional traditional operation was a partial circumcision
or dorsal slit, and these are usually fully sufficient and effective
treatments.
I believe Clemmensen's study is a revolutionary step in the history of the treatment of phimosis,
this study establishes a scientific basis and medical indications for an individual approach to phimosis treatment, ... as is appropriate
for our culture.
Diagnosis and Appropriate
Treatment
Please firstly accurately diagnose the physical appearance of your
condition: check under Phimosis
Research that yours is the typical sort of phimotic ring. (With
the "monotonous clinical appearance" of a thin strip of tight
tissue which is embedded in the inner foreskin). Contact
me or the forums if this is not the case.
Following Clemmensen's findings, some forms of phimotic ring will
stretch, others will not.
To understand this subject, it will help to understand
LSA: lichen sclerosus atrophicus... Lichen means some sort of mixture
between fungi and algae, sclerosus means scarring, atrophic means
degenerative, --- it seems simple phimotic rings stretch, but when
they are connected with "degenerative fungal scarrings"
(LSA) they don't
(Clemmensen distinguishes at least 3 forms of this ring) At times
a simple primary phimotic ring can degenerate to a "fibrotic"
ring --- By stretching what we're doing is making elastic, and reversing
this atrophic (degenerative) process.
From what I've heard a primary phimotic ring doesn't vanish, once
stretched it needs stretching every couple of days ... but you'll
find it gets easier to stretch, ... its on the way to regenerating
... (more from this explanation)
Therefore:
1) If the subject has a primary or congenital phimosis, i.e. ever since
he can remember, then there is every reason to believe that gentle
stretching will mobilise the elastic capacity of the skin tissue.
2) If on the other hand he can remember the phimotic ring developing
then it is most probably a secondary phimosis of a lichenoid or fibrous
type, such types are atrophic (prone to degeneration), they will generally
be difficult to stretch and require surgery. |
2 i) A fibrous type of ring develops often around the age of 70,
but can ocurr anytime after age approx 24 yrs - stretching with betamethasone may help.
2 ii) There is the possibility of a lichenoid phimosis which we
can assume is a pre stage of LSA. If there is an infection present,
this will almost certainly be LSA (also called balanitis). The classical
manifestation of LSA are scar like ivory coloured patches located on
the glans.here, stretching with Clobetasol
Propionate may help
METHODS OF TREATMENT
Stretching
Stretching is an effective treatment for primary "simple"
phimosis. This must be understood as a temporary measure, however
the daily stretching may become an enjoyable pastime and it becomes
easier to stretch. Various methods are reported. Please see Stretching - Please note, for children stretching exercises and experiments
with creams and steroids can be far more disturbing than surgery.
Steroids
The use of Kenalog, Betamethasone and Clobetasol Propionate are
recently reported to have considerable success - even without stretching.
- If you wish to experiment on the frontiers of skin regeneration
- please see Betamethasone
SURGERY
Dorsal Slit - (non-amputative surgery)
There are at least two operations which are referred to as dorsal
slits (dorsal meaning top side). The traditional dorsal slit
is probably the simplest method of alleviating the restriction;
modern "plastic" options are also discussed.
Circumcision and Partial Circ.
For some men full circumcision is an attractive choice of treatment.
A full circumcision is also the least problematic form of treatment
simply because it is easily available and doctors are familiar and
experienced with a number of successful methods. For the treatment
of a phimotic ring a partial
circumcision (sometimes mistakenly called "loose
circumcision") is all that is necessary and thus an important
option. This will involve a little persuasions talent with most
doctors, takes around ten stitches, and will provide a satisfying
answer for most men. For variations on this theme, please see circumcision. and post. circ
problems
Degree of Phimosis related to Treatment
Full Phimosis where the foreskin is fully unretractable when
either flaccid or erect. - (An operation would probably entail a partial
circumcision).
Partial Phimosis when erect retraction will reveal most of the
glans, but the band of tight skin will hinder complete retraction.
When flaccid retraction of the foreskin with this degree of phimosis
will reveal the hourglass
effect. - If operated to release enough loose skin a miniature
dorsal slit probably suffices.
Relative Phimosis is invisible and unnoticeable when flaccid,
will cause difficulties by retraction and the hourglass effect when erect. - To allow free retraction an operation
requires only 4 or 5 mini Z plasty slits.
LSA
Infections develop easily in the humid almost subtropical preputial
zones and require dry surroundings to heal. The only safe recommendation
if an infection has developed is to recommend a full circumcision.
Cleanliness and regularly wearing the foreskin retracted are probably
the simplest methods of preventing lichenoid conditions from developing
in the first place.
Please see Lichen Schlerosus
Index for the latest experiments and maybe success with conservative
non-operative treatments - (including homeopathy)
______________
EXTRA NOTES
Wait and See What Happens
Øster's advice has been
misinterpreted, exaggerated and widely accepted. Boys and men often
report that they were advised to wait and see what happens. This most
useless piece of information was even given to my father at the age
of 76. - (Øster checked and educated his boys every year for
7 years - His study does not show the effects of "normal development"
it shows the effects of checking and educating for 7 yrs!)
Diferent Perspectives and Individual Wishes
Boys who are consciously aware of difficulty by retraction often
want a circumcision, (and they are often dissuaded). If a boy wants
a circumcision then he should certainly have it - even if his phimosis
could be treated with less severe measures. On the other hand with late operations on childhood conditions where the glans has
never previously been exposed, men can be extremely disturbed about
the idea of losing the foreskin, simply because it is all they`ve ever
seen or identified with their manhood. (more
on different perspectives). and they do not realise that there
is any other cure except circumcision.
A word of practical caution is also necessary about adult operations. Adult post circ.
problems - I would always advise that any adult who has never
previously exposed the glans, attempt stretching and then at all
costs attempt to find a urologist or surgeon who will first perform
minimal surgery (a dorsal slit or partial circumcision). |